Page
Twenty-One
05 JULY 2005
The other side of the tourist tracks...
|
|||
Violent Holiday Weekend Continues by Cristina Domingues/ Hank Graf Photo by Kyle Johnson Published Jul 04, 2005 Rochester police are investigating the city's latest shooting. Police were called to Remington St. around 2:15 Monday morning. When they arrived, they found a 25-year-old man shot in the back. He was taken to Strong Hospital. Police are still trying to figure out if the shooting was a result of a potential robbery or an on-going dispute. |
Again...
|
|||
Shooting Victim Dies of Injuries by Greg Johnston & Lisa Carino File photo Published Jul 03, 2005 A 34 year-old man who was shot in May died from his injuries Saturday. Rochester Police say David Cooper Powell was shot on May 19 in his vehicle on Teralta Street. He was struck several times in the upper back. Powell had been hospitalized since the incident. Police have no suspects. |
And again...
|
|||
Accidental Shooting Ends With Death by Greg Johnston & Lisa Carino Photo by Kyle Johnson Published Jul 03, 2005 Rochester Police have ruled a fatal shooting on North Clinton Avenue Saturday night an accident. The shooting happened in the backyard of 1358 North Clinton Avenue. Police say Edgar Gonzales, 23, was shot once in the head. He was pronounced dead a short time later at the hospital. Investigators say Glenn Taylor, 26, of Cleveland, Ohio had the handgun that accidentally fired and shot Gonzales. Taylor was charged with manslaughter and criminal possession of a weapon. |
Yet again...
|
|||
Murder Suspect in Court By Deanna Russo & Lisa Carino File photo Published Jul 02, 2005 A Rochester man was in court Saturday morning facing murder charges. Police charged Lamar Roundtree, 22, for the death of Lisa Baker, 35, who was shot in the back June 26. Police arrested Roundtree on Lyell Avenue just after 6:30 Friday night. Roundtree is charged with second-degree murder. |
Another...
|
|||
Man Charged in Toddler Shooting by Leah George Photo By: Andrew Heinze Published Jun 30, 2005 The man arrested for allegedly shooting a toddler earlier this week was arraigned in city court. James Rivera, 21, of Rochester faces three felony charges in connection with the shooting. Rivera pleaded not guilty to reckless endangerment and two counts criminal possession of a weapon. Because Rivera did have a prior criminal record it was illegal for him to have the .22-caliber handgun. In his written statement, Rivera told police he was wiping down the handgun late Monday night, when his shirt got caught on the trigger and accidentally fired a shot. The bullet went through 2-year-old DeTavious Wynn’s upper thigh. Rivera turned himself into police while they were looking for him in his neighborhood two days later. DeTavious Wynn spent a couple of days in the hospital. His mom, Candy Wynn, says he's back home and feeling like himself. Candy says the incident was just a bad situation. "Accidents happen. I'm thanking god that didn't nothin' happen to him to harm him, as in him dying or something like that. Let justice be served that's how I see it. However the court handles it, that's how they handle it. They’ve got him now, so I mean whatever the crime is and how the crime went then let it be served let the court system do it," Wynn said. According to Rivera's statement, after the shooting, he dropped the gun so he could pick up the toddler and bring him to his mother. Police won't say whether they recovered that gun. Rivera's in jail on $10,000 dollars bail. He's scheduled to be back in court next week for a preliminary hearing. |
More tragedy...
|
|||
Wilkins St. Death Ruled a Homicide
by Greg Johnston/ Hank Graf File Photo Published Jun 30, 2005 A 53-year-old Rochester grandmother found dead last week on Wilkins St. was murdered. That is the official word coming from the Monroe County Medical Examiner's office on Wednesday. Investigators say Annett Wyche was shot in the head. A pair of potential buyers discovered her body on June 21. No arrests have been made. Anyone with information is asked to call police. |
Suburbanites included...
|
|||
Fairport Man Hurt in City Shooting
by Rich Turner/ Hank Graf File Photo Published Jun 29, 2005 Rochester police have identified the man shot on Dewey Ave. on Wednesday. Police say someone shot Kevin Lewis, 24, of Fairport after a fight at a home on Dewey Avenue. Investigators say Lewis was shot with a small caliber gun. He was taken to Strong Hospital, where he is now in satisfactory condition. Investigators hope to interview Lewis to find out more about the incident. Police have not made an arrest. |
OK. So why re-publicize less than a week's worth of depressing ugliness in front of the world?
No... it's not to dissuade visitors from checking out this area nor is it to illustrate and emphasize the ills of a moderate-sized city in Upstate New York.
It's not to show that the Rochester area has any more violent crime than any other comparable-sized metropolitan area in the States nor is it to make any sort of a statement on the proliferation of firearms.
It's to show a possible reason why the ferry isn't packed to the dinghies with Canadian tourists. See, for better or worse, Canadian society doesn't see firearm possession as a 'Right'; it's very much a 'Privilege' which can be taken away easier than it's granted. That by no means is the answer to why homicide rates are lower in urban areas of Ontario, but it certainly gives Canadians reason to pause and consider whether they want hop on a boat to a community which grinds out stories of shootings on almost a daily basis.
Clean up your house. THEN invite the guests. Nobody's comfortable dropping by when the family and friends are in the middle of some raging battle.
Since Friday, the local cable news is reporting 3,000 folks have taken the ferry (today's figures aren't tallied as of yet).
Does a single passenger making a round trip count as 'two passenger trips'? If so, the actual number of passengers can be conveniently inflated to indicate a grander acceptance than in reality. 1,000 people making a round-trip can suddenly be interpreted as 2,000 passengers.
3,000 in three days isn't bad but it needs to be remembered (1) this is a holiday weekend on both sides of the lake and people have an extra day to travel and (2) the magic number of 1,056 per day (the estimate the city of Rochester has projected) is barely being met. On perhaps one of the most ideal weekends of the entire summer travel season. With ideal weather to be on the lake. On the first weekend of the re-started service.
Still look great? Well, maybe... but let's see if the momentum keeps up. If even under the most ideal conditions, passenger numbers are barely meeting the estimates for each and every day -- and not much more -- how does next Tuesday's regular work-day schedule look? Or in the middle of October? It's one thing to catch a 40-50 mph breeze on the lake on a hot, muggy July day... it's quite another thing on a raw 40˚F overcast November afternoon.
Will that stop local ferry supporters from jumping up and down cheering, "It WORKS, it WORKS!!" and claiming victory over us naysayers? Not a chance. We've been on THIS milk run once before, remember? The last time (notwithstanding the dismal first day of public service by CATS... when the boat was virtually empty) after a few thousand passengers experienced the Big Excitement, ferry cheerleaders were feeling haughty and vindicated. ("SEE?? Told you so!!") . Eleven weeks later, CATS was calling it quits. Do we remember THAT scenario?
C a r e f u l , now. Don't want to risk being flagrantly premature in reporting first-quarter earnings before the first week of service has even been completed. Especially since the CATS version didn't even last long enough to FINISH a quarter. No matter. It's easy to forget the true purpose of a business (you know... longevity, profits... that sort of stuff) when the local media can just as easily manufacture hype with beaming faces of happy passengers which satisfies ferry supporters' demands for hopeful optimism.
How 'bout this for balanced reporting?
|
"Yeah, it was OK. Different, but sorta pricy. Do it again? Nah, don't think so." "Well, it took an hour to get to Cherry Street and they said we had to be at the terminal an hour before departure. We're trying to find our friends from Fairport; they say it takes about forty minutes to get to their place... guess there's some sort of construction somewhere. We'll probably drive next time." "Hey... they just said the nearest hotel is on West Ridge Road! Can we walk there? ... No? .... Waitta minute... Lake Avenue bus to Ridge Road.... Ridge Road bus... west past Mt. Read Boulevard to... ahhh, to hell with it... we'll call a cab." |
Nope. 100% customer satisfaction is a guarantee. And the news footage proves it... right?
The Saw-It-On-TV-Read-It-In-The-Newspaper 'Proof'. Two dozen positive responses are enough to confirm the Second Coming as an unqualified success. For now, anyway.
No problem here. As long as the thing pays for itself, they could have Wayne Newton blowing kisses on board for all I care. But if this turns into a another money-losing proposition, there's going to be more than just naysayers to contend with.
And THAT'S a guarantee.
07 JULY 2005
Taking a step back and looking carefully:
|
|
| Home > News > Local News |
|
My goodness; the good news just keeps on coming, yes?
Basically, as Rochester area residents snicker at the Buffalo area neighbours for their dismal economic outlook, it looks like the Monroe County finances are heading in the very same direction. Who's laughing now, you smug hotshots?
Meanwhile, back at the corral...
|
|||
The CAT's First Weekend A Hit
by Mary McCombs Published Jul 05, 2005 The long holiday weekend spelled success for the fast ferry re-launch in Charlotte. The new owner of the ship says the vessel carried 34-hundred passengers and 800 cars this past weekend. (Hey Mary! Why not just write 'Seventeen-hundred score'? '34-hundred'? Where did you get your Doctorate in English Literature??) Bay Ferries doesn't expect the ferry to sell out for the first week or two. The ship did see new and repeat customers at the Port of Rochester. (Does the passenger who rides over -- then rides back -- count as a 'repeat customer'? Doesn't that count as two passenger trips?) "It was exciting. I mean there were a lot of people here that had never ridden the ferry before, so they were excited about doing it. The comments coming off the ferry were just really, really positive," says Glenn Gardner of Bay Ferries. (Nobody's saying it isn't fun. All we're saying is: it can't survive as a business. Period.) Businesses inside the terminal are excited that the fast ferry is up and running. They saw an increase in traffic which translated into customers. "It was great. We are averaging what we did in one day over this weekend as what we were doing in a week with the boat not running. It was very good, it was a big relief," says Bill Briggs, owner of a floral and gift shop. (Ever hear the expression, "Make hay while the sun's still shining"?) Bay Ferries says the summer season is just starting and the company is hoping to book more passengers on a trip to Toronto. |
Stuff 'n nonsense. Who's kidding who? Are local Rochester area residents really that gullible to latch on to the latest bons mots and conclude the ferry has achieved salvation? They can't really... no, they wouldn't be so...
No, by the tone of the emails, there are a significant and quiet segment of the local community who are as jaded about this thing as I am. Strangely, the demise of the ferry as a business seems secondary compared to the wrath aimed at Mayor Bill; I mean, this Mayor is NOT being spoken of too kindly by locals. Me? Ehhh, Mayor Bill is a bit pompous for my tastes but inept bumbling happens in any organization. Just look at Kodak.
No, Bill Johnson is just ONE contributor to the ferry fiasco... any Rochester area resident who didn't express an opinion against the CATS' proposal is another. Any Rochester City Councilperson who didn't vote against the proposal is another, as is any politician who voted to send a cheque for this project. The blame cannot be laid strictly on any one person.
Even Toronto has its share of the culpable. Had Toronto simply said, "Thank you very much indeed, we're flattered, but we don't have the facilities to handle the ship nor do we believe we have the demand", the entire debacle would have never taken wing. There might not have been any reason to hurl sweet nothings like calling Rochester an 'armpit' which is a 'ferry bad place'. Now that the dirty laundry's been aired, when the ferry bites the dust for the second -- and final -- time, the hard feelings will linger long after the ferry's sailed up the St.Lawrence. The true Toronto opinion of Rochester has been leaked out, inspired by some cheesy attempt to get into the Major Leagues. Rochester is no player. Maybe at one time it was, but the bloom is definitely off THIS rose.
|
|
<<•••• How Rochester views Toronto |
|
|
How Toronto views Rochester ••••>> |
Hmmm. Looks like we've got an image problem here.
"Y'all c'mon down an' gitcher GARBAGE PLATE, y'hear?"
Yeah. Whatever.
On to other good news:
The Golden Lining. The balm that soothes. Shootings are up, but deaths are down. Oh, I just feel like bursting into song!
Now... what was the 'good' news? More of those shot are surviving? That's a pretty strange claim to be of good cheer but when the chips are down, looking for anything positive becomes an imperative.
As long as the bash hammer's out:
|
|||
Poll Shows Confidence is Down Here
by Jim Aroune/Linda Loy Published Jul 06, 2005 A new Siena College poll showed consumer confidence in Greater Rochester was down in the second quarter. This area ranked fifth out of the six regions in New York polled. Consumers’ confidence in the Rochester economy's future also declined this spring. |
OK. For 2005, consumer confidence in Greater Rochester has been down for the first half of the year.
Let's recap. From the local news, over the course of the past two days we learn that:
(1) Monroe County's rating by Fitch Ratings has dropped to three notches above junk bond status,
(2) city shootings are up over 21% from this time last year and
(3) Greater Rochester consumer confidence has been declining since the beginning of this year.
And now we've taken on a business which has not only failed less than 12 months ago, but has been expected to lose another $725,000 in the first year alone. We're positively giddy here.
But don't try to use that 'funny' money down here. It's just not 'cost effective' for us and we're one business-savvy community. Just ask Fitch Ratings.
09 JULY 2005
First, a disturbing use of public funding for private purposes (sound familiar?)...
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Followed by an example of the 'family-friendly' Rochester area...
|
|||
Boy, 12, Killed on City's East Side
by Anthony Pascale & Lisa Carino Published Jul 09, 2005 Rochester police are looking for whoever shot and killed a 12 year-old boy late Friday Night. Police say Frederick Lewis was walking down Langham Street with two other boys when a man with a gun began following them. Moments later the suspect began firing. The boys started running and ended up behind a house. That's where police say they found Lewis, who was taken to Strong Memorial Hospital where he was pronounced dead. The boy's friend, Anthony Williams, 17, was also shot. Williams suffered non-life-threatening injuries. Police don't know why the suspect targeted the boys. No arrests have been made. Anyone with information on this homicide should call 911. |
The Rochester Rhinos is a local privately owned soccer club which plays its home games on Frontier Field, the undomed ballpark built near downtown Rochester which has yet to turn a profit since it opened. The former County Executive Jack Doyle, initially promised Frontier Field wouldn't cost the local taxpayer a dime to build. It didn't; it ended up costing the taxpayers a mountain of dimes and is a lovely retro ballpark confection which collects litter and snow for over six months of the year.
It's a decent ballpark as far as small urban ballparks go (hell, it better be), but it's as pretentious as a Disneyworld Main Street. Plopped down in the middle of an urban desert (the 'Entertainment District' of High Falls is a dusty trek to the east), Frontier Field and PaeTec Park are immediately surrounded by absolutely nothing a visitor would find interesting. The locals prize the area for it's vast spread of parking lots because that's the use most in demand for... you guessed it... Frontier Field and PaeTec Park. The Corporate HQ of Eastman Kodak looms large as the backdrop for the sports fans, possible evoking those warm memories of local days l o n g gone.
Like the spoiled, overly-pampered neighbourhood kids, the Rhinos management pissed and moaned about how they 'needed' a separate sports venue to call Their Very Own as Lord Knows the ignominy of having to play second fiddle on someone else's turf is just too great to bear. So the Triple-Chinned Suits get together, wallow up to the public trough with wistful looks on their porcine faces and the Good Ol Boy Network gets busy.
Voila! Cash o'plenty is secured for another private Wish List even though the rich kids have to spend their part-time job money on actually paying for their own toys. How unreasonable, seeing as the local population are the minions who are ostensibly the Grand Beneficiaries of such a magnificent diversion. Or so the rationale goes.
So even though the vast majority of Rochester area residents will never set foot in either Frontier Field or PaeTec Park, they'll be expected to pay for those who don't think they should have to foot the bill for their own indulgences.
PaeTec Park, yet another privately branded venue paid for with public funds, is located a stone's throw from Frontier Field and one can only presume the litter and snow which hasn't been caught by the undomed Frontier Field will be snagged by the undomed PaeTec Park. Few businesses closed 50% of the year are robust revenue generators... I don't know why, they just aren't.
And while the Rhinos management stresses over whether they'll get another $10 to $15 million from the state to be able to tack on a second deck of plastic seats to their baby, a 12-year old boy is shot dead in the streets of Rochester less than a mile-and-a-half away.
Local priorities, doncha know? Tens upon tens of millions of dollars for duplicate sports venues and failed ferry projects, but closing schools and slashing social programs aimed at addressing social problems just seems to be 'tightening the belt'. Priorities indeed.
"Dude... you're wandering again..."
Well, maybe just a little bit. See... strategic community development is a concerted effort which assembles and integrates the strengths of a locality with a realistic and pragmatic assessment executed in a united effort. Fancy way of saying, "Let's get real, work together and not pretend that we're something we aren't, but focus on what we are".
I won't delve into the horrendous loss of historic buildings and heritage sites which the locals have bulldozed and replaced with a plaque. Or painted with a pretentious architectural brush and reinvented as an economic 'attraction'. No... if I do that, I might really get snarky.
The ferry is but one aspect of a general lack of realistic vision and a realistic master plan for the Rochester area. Is it realistic to expect residents of a nation's largest metropolitan area to find enough unique and interesting things to see and do in a much smaller urban area... to the point of taking a pricy and no-faster method of transportation? Does some private company -- which has no previous experience -- stumbling onto the scene with an untested proposal amount to an example of a realistic long-range master plan?
This weekend is the annual Corn Hill Arts Festival. It's extremely popular and a nice summer diversion held in a gentrified residential section close to downtown. The festival itself is unique; the concept is not. Every city has some sort of festival/block party/food fair/arts festival... so this just happens to be another one in the festival series in summertime Rochester.
|
|||
Corn Hill Fest Bigger, Better
by Yevette Collins Published Jul 09, 2005 The Corn Hill Arts Festival just seems to get better with age. In its 37th year, there are new bands, a more interactive children's area and a wide variety of food vendors. Nearly half the artists are new to the festival this year, but some of the favorites from recent years are back. While the festival focuses mainly on the arts, it's also about helping the community.
"We produce about $100,000 for the community, from artists’ fees and the food vendors, and with that we do low interest loans, we do philanthropy,” said Bonny Mayer, the festival’s chairperson. “Last year, for example, we gave a large donation to the city for a playground. I believe the playground cost about $85,000." The festival runs through the weekend. It’s open Sunday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. |
This is the sort of local attraction community 'leaders' hope will compel Torontonians to hop on the ferry and zip on down. Is it worth it? Depends on the visitor. Spending a few hundred dollars for a weekend in Rochester to attend an arts festival as the main attraction might not be seen as a whimsical extravagance to some, while others might see it as a very poor value considering the cost and location.
The ferry supporters are banking on there being enough of those high-flyers to support the service... either as a result of attractions such as the Corn Hill Arts Festival or by word of mouth from satisfied customers. Will it work? No, that's already been proven once before. Will it stumble along until financial humanitarians put it out of its misery? Yeah, that's my guess... but just how long that'll take is yet to be determined.
Sorry... had to post this tidbit.
|
|||
Corn Hill Sales Down
by Jessica Williams photo by Nate Kramer Published Jul 10, 2005 Though it was a banner day for a festival, it wasn't exactly a banner year for the Corn Hill Arts Festival. At least that's what many of the vendors reported. Some say sales were so slow this year down as much as 80 percent they won't return next year. Organizers say they welcome the turnover in vendors. Seven hundred crafters applied for 444 vendor slots. Parking also became an issue this year. Festival visitors were told to park in city garages and hop on the free shuttle service. But the civic center garage hiked the price to park to seven dollars. "We're going to take a serious look next year at possibly having the college or something like that, and pull people in on the buses, so that number one it would be free, and two we could accommodate more people," said Bonny Mayer, of the Corn Hill Arts Festival. An estimated 200,000 people visited the festival this weekend. |
And so it goes. I guess an outsider could draw at least two conclusions here.
(1) Public transportation service is so crappy in this area, organizers of the Corn Hill Arts Festival don't even bother to consider it as a viable alternative to the car.
(2) Festival organizers aren't particularly targeting those area residents who use public transportation. The residents who do use public transportation primarily live in the city of Rochester; these aren't the 'high-spenders'... to put it delicately.
Either way, the Rochester area religion of Sprawl just keeps on hammering away at the local economy. That translates to some self-defeating tourism initiatives which sees a much smaller community posing far greater challenges to visitors trying to get around without a car than their home community which is vastly larger in terms of population and geographic area.
And the ferry service begins to look less attractive. The ferry failure is a symptom of some larger underlying reasons which have been spelled out here... repeatedly.
Shuttles suck. They're nothing but a band-aid approach to solving problems and people use them only as a last resort.... regardless of cost or lack thereof. And since the Civic Centre parking garage (closest public parking venue to Corn Hill) bumped its rate for the event, it can be argued the shuttle wasn't exactly 'free'.
Small town mentality translates into small town efforts. And when some of the intended patrons are from one of the largest metropolitan areas in North America, serving up the equivalent of the Mayberry Pie and Jam Festival isn't going to fly. To be sure, 200K festival attendees is nothing to sneeze at but quite obviously the presence of a 'fast' ferry service from Toronto didn't empty the Provincial capital this past weekend. From the numbers, it didn't even make any difference at Festival attendance or vendor sales.
Next?
|
|||
City Police Officer Shoots Girl, 13
by Leah George/Seth Voorhees Photo by Tim Keegan Published Jul 11, 2005 Rochester police say the shooting of a 13 year old girl by a city police officer appears justified. Acting Rochester Police Chief Cedric Alexander says a number of eyewitness statements corroborate Officer Mark Simmons' claim that the shooting victim was coming at both the officer and the girl's older sister with an 8-inch kitchen knife. Lashedica Mason, 13, is listed in guarded condition at Strong Memorial Hospital. Friends of the family say the officer shot her three times. Chief Alexander confirms that the girls was hit in the finger, the arm and the abdomen. Family members tell R News that girl's gall bladder was removed in surgery earlier Monday. Police say they were called to Mason's home on St. Jacob Street around 10:30 p.m. Sunday because Mason locked herself in a bathroom and was threatening to commit suicide. The chief was asked if officer Simmons had an opportunity to use less-lethal force -- such as a taser -- or handle the situation differently. “This was not an opportunity to employ any other technique or measure whatsoever,” said Alexander. “If we could have, we would have.” Neighbors who know Mason call her "B.B." They describe her as a quiet girl who keeps to herself. "She was a nice young girl. She never came out of the house. She never bothered no one. You hardly ever see her," said neighbor and family friend Jacqueline Horn. Horn said two days ago, “B.B.” helped her older sister do Horn’s hair. She said, "last night 'B.B.' played basketball with my son." Rochester mayor William Johnson cancelled a trip to Boston so that he could stay in Rochester to follow up on this incident. Johnson says he personally read each of the statements signed by the witnesses and by Officer Simmons. Johnson backs the chief's assessment that the shooting was justified. “This all happened in a matter of seconds,” said Johnson. “This is verified by the family’s account.” Chief Alexander was out of town at the time of the incident and returned to Rochester late Monday morning. |
Now before anybody gets their knickers in a knot, I'm not about to debate whether this shooting was justified or not. What I WILL do is point out this REALLY looks bad to the folks across the lake. People don't read the fine print; they barely get past the headline and somehow, "City Police Officer Shoots Girl, 13" or "Boy, 12, Killed on City's East Side" isn't too good for tourism.
How's that for understatement? Profoundly sad, but true.
Mail call.
|
||||||||
you might try to offer constructive criticism instead of always showing the bad side. there's a lot of good happening in the Rochester area. |
Fair enough. There's plenty of 'good happening' in the Rochester area. So what's the point? There's plenty of 'good happening' in every community. It's easy enough for local 'leaders' and media to focus on the positive and gloss over the negative instead of addressing the problems upfront. Frankly, the self-adulation the local ferry boosters have been demonstrating has gone on far too long without a less Pollyanna-ish view. Presenting that view is constructive criticism provided it's taken in that context.
If simply not marching in lock-step with the rest of the gang amounts to destructive criticism, it's small wonder innovative change for the better doesn't happen too often around here. There are no shortages of people singing the praises of Rochester... that blind, obedient adulation might explain why even the most idiotic of ideas, like some 'fast' ferry service, could gain support simply on the basis of exaggerated civic pride.
Of course, if 'we' only want to show the 'good happening' in the Rochester area, 'we' had better not report our news in the various forms of mass media. That way, 'we' can keep the prospective visitors from seeing daily life in our area. I think that's referred to as 'sanitizing' the news. Strangely, in an age of instant internet connectivity 'we' seem to think nobody outside the immediate region is watching us.
Guess again. The hits to this one
tiny corner of the internet are coming from around the world -- which is amazing
to some (me) and possibly unnerving to others (ferry supporters).
Haven't seen a noticeable increase in the number of Ontario plates on cars, but I don't get out much around here. I'll be in Toronto this coming weekend and will no doubt be inundated with questions about the attractions in Rochester. </sarcasm>